Quote of the Day: “The government solution to a problem is usually as bad as the problem.” Milton Friedman
Wow – what a busy Monday. Lots of articles to comment on – it seems that our friends at TheRecord had a very productive (cough) weekend. First up is another “DEFANGING BIG TECH” column – but this time, it’s actually filed under the “Opinion” label on page A7. Even more interesting is the little blurb they have under their “DEFANGING…” logo: “Multinational tech giants keep getting bigger at the expense of domestic media and competitiveness. This ongoing series looks at the challenge for governments, and how they should respond.” Nice… So, it’s not the fault of the old, dead tree media companies who had virtual monopoly on information distribution for the last 200 year, nope – it’s now a “government” issue. What arrogance. The author of today’s column is Navneet Alang, a freelancer from Toronto. He tells us that: “Minister of Innovation, Science and Industry Navdeep Bains has tabled a bill called the Digital Charter Implementation Act, which looks to modernize Canada’s approach to how companies handle the personal information they collect about Canadians. If passed, the bill would ensure Canadians had the right to destroy their own data…”. O.K. – I’m not exactly sure how this would work since data points about an individual are intermingled with data points on other individuals so this seems to be a rather complex issue. It’s not like Google or TheBay or Canadian Tire have a single record about me that they can easily drop. Of course I haven’t read the bill and I don’t know what “destroy their own data” actually means and it appears that Alang hasn’t read it either since he doesn’t tell us. But he let’s us know that: “It follows another announcement by the Trudeau government that promised to expand broadband access to almost all the country by 2030. So far, so good, right?” Well, no it’s not good, but then I guess what TorStar writer ever saw a Liberal spending plan they didn’t like? I wrote a piece for another site that went through both the physical problems with broadband rollout “to almost all the country” and the actual cost per line of last 2 percent. Horrendous with today’s technology – but who knows what will happen in 10 years. Maybe this might be cost effective – but it clearly isn’t now. Of course, almost 95% of Canadians have broadband in their primary residences now – so, oh wait – what’s my quote of the day??? Alang’s column jumps overboard without a PFD when he suggests governments should take over basic services: “…it might help us rethink what the role of the state is in relation to the internet. Right now, governments act as overseers of the internet: a body that mostly keeps out of how private companies behave, occasionally stepping in with regulation such as this new bill. Yet, in many other aspects of life — transportation, utilities, health care — the government considers it a responsibility to actually provide basic services to its citizens.” Yup – the greatest invention in the history of the world, and this idiot wants governments to take over. Of course, transportation, utilities, health care are such wonderful examples of how efficient and effective governments are. Not sure why he didn’t include education in there as well? I guess this moron doesn’t realize that only when governments got out of the way and deregulated the various services he talks about, this is when they started to grow into their potential. I can still remember how trucks had to unload their goods at the U.S. / Canada border because they couldn’t cross into each others countries. Taking an airplane trip somewhere was only something rich people did 50 year ago. Now we fly to New York or Florida for a long weekend. I remember when you could only get 1200 baud modems from Bell since they refused to allow other devices on their lines and when a call to Preston from Kitchener was actually a long distance call. Now you can call India on Zoom for nothing. I could go on but my age is showing… The author brings up a couple of other really stupid ideas that I can’t be bothered to bring up but tries to salvage his article by saying: “Some of these ideas could work, and some may, upon further inspection, fall flat.” Really??? Completely clueless, but par for the TorStar course, and these DEFANGING articles, I guess…
By the way, Alang’s article took up the top half of page A7. But guess what was on the bottom half of the page? It was an advert for the St. Mary’s Hospital Foundation begging for money to purchase equipment. What a brilliant advertisement placement and completely fitting for the loser column on top. This is exactly what your internet would look like if government took over…
Good editorial today regarding the brutal judicial patronage appointments that the Trudeau government has made. Worth the three minute read. But what’s not worth the three minute read is Geoffrey Stevens’ column on why Trudeau should invoke the old War Measures Act, now updated to the better sounding, but just as authoritarian, Emergencies Act to fight COVID-19. Seriously, does Stevens have naked pictures of Jim Poling? Just wondering how this guy gets to write the drivel he comes up with every Monday.
And speaking of wasted space, TorStar’s Bob Hepburn has suffered from stage 4 TDS even before there was such a thing as TDS. Like most of his fellow sufferers, Trump = Hitler. His column in the Opinion page tells us about the Eight Ways O’Toole is copying Trump’s playbook. Of course, all of his “playbook” suggestions are just basic politics, but if you can blame anything of Trump, I guess Hepburn will. So, Trump = Hitler and O’Toole = Trump so therefore O’Toole = Hitler. And so it begins…
I was reading an online article at TheRecord.com from a TorStar columnist and this little blurb was in the middle of my page: “If you refuse to settle for second hand news and think that your loved ones shouldn’t either, give them the gift of The Record.” Way too funny…